The “Donut Effect” is real
Our Cookie Policy has been updated! The Conference Board uses cookies to improve our website, enhance your experience, and deliver relevant messages and offers about our products. Detailed information on the use of cookies on this site is provided in our cookie policy. For more information on how The Conference Board collects and uses personal data, please visit our privacy policy. By continuing to use this Site or by clicking "OK", you acknowledge our privacy policy and consent to the use of cookies.  Our Privacy Policy has been updated! Detailed information on the use of cookies on this site is provided in our cookie policy and our privacy policy. 
TCB Tourch
Loading...
  • logoImage
  •  
    • US
    • EUROPE
    • ASIA
  • 2

    Close
    • Insights
        • Insights
        • Explore by Center
          • Explore by Center
          • CED
            Committee for Economic Development

          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

        • Explore by Content Type
          • Explore by Content Type
          • Reports

          • Upcoming Webcasts

          • On Demand Webcasts

          • Podcasts

          • Charts & Infographics

        • Trending Topics
          • Trending Topics
          • Artificial Intelligence (AI)

          • Navigating Washington

          • Geopolitics

          • US Economic Forecast

          • Sustainability

          • Future of Work

    • Events
        • Events
        • Upcoming Events
          • Upcoming Events
          • People First: Opportunity and Access

          • CHRO Summit: Navigating through a Tsunami of Change

          • Future: People Asia

          • Executive Compensation in a Disruptive World

          • CED Distinguished Leadership Awards Celebration

          • The 2025 IBI/Conference Board Health and Productivity Forum

          • Explore all Upcoming Events

        • Member-Exclusive Programs
          • Member-Exclusive Programs
          • Center Briefings

          • Experts Live

          • Roundtables

          • Working Groups

          • Expert Briefings

    • Data
        • Data
        • Consumer Confidence Index

        • Data Central

        • TCB Benchmarking

        • Employment Trends Index

        • Global Economic Outlook

        • Leading Economic Indicators

        • Help Wanted OnLine

        • Labor Markets

        • Measure of CEO Confidence

        • Human Capital Benchmarking &
          Data Analytics

        • CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

    • Centers
        • Centers
        • Our Centers
          • Our Centers
          • Committee for Economic Development

          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

        • Center Membership
          • Center Membership
          • What Is a Center?

          • Benefits of Center Membership

          • Join a Center

    • Councils
        • Councils
        • Find a Council
          • Find a Council
          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

        • Council Membership
          • Council Membership
          • What is a Council?

          • Benefits of Council Membership

          • Apply to a Council

    • Membership
        • Membership
        • Why Become a Member?
          • Why Become a Member?
          • Benefits of Membership

          • Check if Your Organization is a Member

          • Speak to a Membership Associate

        • Types of Membership
          • Types of Membership
          • Council

          • Committee for Economic Development

          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

          • Insights

        • Already a Member?
          • Already a Member?
          • Sign In to myTCB®

          • Executive Communities

          • Member-Exclusive Programs

    • About Us
        • About Us
        • Who We Are
          • Who We Are
          • About Us

          • In the News

          • Press Releases

          • Our History

          • Support Our Work

          • Locations

          • Contact Us

        • Our Community
          • Our Community
          • Our Leadership

          • Our Experts

          • Trustees

          • Voting Members

          • Global Counsellors

          • Careers

          • This Week @ TCB

    • Careers
    • This Week @ TCB
    • Sign In to myTCB®
      • US
      • EUROPE
      • ASIA
    • Insights
      • Insights
      • Explore by Center
        • Explore by Center
        • CED
          Committee for Economic Development

        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

      • Explore by Content Type
        • Explore by Content Type
        • Reports

        • Upcoming Webcasts

        • On Demand Webcasts

        • Podcasts

        • Charts & Infographics

      • Trending Topics
        • Trending Topics
        • Artificial Intelligence (AI)

        • Navigating Washington

        • Geopolitics

        • US Economic Forecast

        • Sustainability

        • Future of Work

    • Events
      • Events
      • Upcoming Events
        • Upcoming Events
        • People First: Opportunity and Access

        • CHRO Summit: Navigating through a Tsunami of Change

        • Future: People Asia

        • Executive Compensation in a Disruptive World

        • CED Distinguished Leadership Awards Celebration

        • The 2025 IBI/Conference Board Health and Productivity Forum

        • Explore all Upcoming Events

      • Member-Exclusive Programs
        • Member-Exclusive Programs
        • Center Briefings

        • Experts Live

        • Roundtables

        • Working Groups

        • Expert Briefings

    • Data
      • Data
      • Consumer Confidence Index

      • Data Central

      • TCB Benchmarking

      • Employment Trends Index

      • Global Economic Outlook

      • Leading Economic Indicators

      • Help Wanted OnLine

      • Labor Markets

      • Measure of CEO Confidence

      • Human Capital Benchmarking & Data Analytics

      • CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

    • Centers
      • Centers
      • Our Centers
        • Our Centers
        • Committee for Economic Development

        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

      • Center Membership
        • Center Membership
        • What is a Center?

        • Benefits of Center Membership

        • Join a Center

    • Councils
      • Councils
      • Find a Council
        • Find a Council
        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

      • Council Membership
        • Council Membership
        • What is a Council?

        • Benefits of Council Membership

        • Apply to a Council

    • Membership
      • Membership
      • Why Become a Member?
        • Why Become a Member?
        • Benefits of Membership

        • Check if Your Organization is a Member

        • Speak to a Membership Associate

      • Types of Membership
        • Types of Membership
        • Council

        • Committee for Economic Development

        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

        • Insights

      • Already a Member?
        • Already a Member?
        • Sign In to myTCB®

        • Executive Communities

        • Member-Exclusive Programs

    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Who We Are
        • Who We Are
        • About Us

        • In the News

        • Press Releases

        • This Week @ TCB

        • Our History

        • Support Our Work

        • Locations

        • Contact Us

      • Our Community
        • Our Community
        • Our Leadership

        • Our Experts

        • Trustees

        • Voting Members

        • Global Counsellors

        • Careers

        • This Week @ TCB

    • Careers
    • Sign In to myTCB®
    • Download TCB Insights App
  • Insights
    Insights

    Our research and analysis have helped the world's leading companies navigate challenges and seize opportunities for over 100 years.

    Explore All Research

    Economic Indicators

    • Explore by Center
    • CED
      Committee for Economic Development
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    • Explore by Content Type
    • Reports
    • Upcoming Webcasts
    • On Demand Webcasts
    • Podcasts
    • Charts & Infographics
    • Trending Topics
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Navigating Washington
    • Geopolitics
    • US Economic Forecast
    • Sustainability
    • Future of Work
  • Events
    Events

    Our in-person and virtual events offer unmatched opportunities for professional development, featuring top experts and practitioners.

    See Everything Happening This Week

    Sponsor a Program

    • Upcoming Events
    • People First: Opportunity and Access

      June 12 - 13, 2025

      CHRO Summit: Navigating through a Tsunami of Change

      June 24, 2025

      Future: People Asia

      September 04 - 05, 2025

    •  
    • Executive Compensation in a Disruptive World

      September 16 - 17, 2025

      CED Distinguished Leadership Awards Celebration

      October 08, 2025

      The 2025 IBI/Conference Board Health and Productivity Forum

      October 16 - 17, 2025

    • Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Center Briefings
    • Experts Live
    • Roundtables
    • Working Groups
    • Expert Briefings
    • Explore by Type
    • Events
    • Webcasts
    • Podcasts
    • Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Center Briefings
    • Experts Live
    • Roundtables
    • Working Groups
    • Expert Briefings
  • Data
    Corporate Disclosure Data

    TCB Benchmarking

    Real-time data & analytical tools to benchmark your governance, compensation, environmental, human capital management (HCM) and social practices against US public companies.

    Economic Data

    All Data

    See current direction and trends across key indicators

    Consumer Confidence Index

    US consumers' thoughts on the economy, jobs, finances and more

    Data Central

    One-stop, member-exclusive portal for the entire suite of indicators

    Labor Markets

    Covering all aspects of labor markets, from monthly development to long-term trends

    Measure of CEO Confidence

    Examines the health of the US economy from the perspective of CEOs

     

    Recession & Growth Trackers

    See the current and future state of 16 economies.

    Global Economic Outlook

    Track the latest short-, medium-, and long-term growth outlooks for 77 economies

    Leading Economic Indicators

    Track the state of the business cycle for 12 global economies across Asia and Europe

    Help Wanted OnLine

    Track the status of job markets across the US through online job listings

    Other Featured Data

    Human Capital Analytics Tools

    Tools to understand human capital management and corporate performance

    CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

    Tracks the impact, resources, and satisfaction of CMOs and CCOs

  • Centers
    Centers

    Centers offer access to world-class experts, research, events, and senior executive communities.

    Our Centers
    • Committee for Economic Development
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    Center Membership
    • What Is a Center?
    • Benefits of Center Membership
    • Join a Center
  • Councils
    Councils

    Councils are invitation-only, peer-led communities of senior executives that come together to exchange knowledge, accelerate career development, and advance their function.

    Find a Council
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    Council Membership
    • What Is a Council?
    • Benefits of Council Membership
    • Apply to a Council
  • Membership
    Membership

    Membership in The Conference Board arms your team with an arsenal of knowledge, networks, and expertise that's unmatched in scope and depth.

    • Why Become a Member?
    • Benefits of Membership
    • Check if Your Organization is a Member
    • Speak to a Membership Associate
    • Types of Membership
    • Council
    • Committee for Economic Development
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    • Insights
    • Already a Member?
    • Sign in to myTCB®
    • Executive Communities
    • Member-Exclusive Programs
  • About Us
    About Us

    The Conference Board is the global, nonprofit think tank and business membership organization that delivers Trusted Insights for What's Ahead®. For over 100 years, our cutting-edge research, data, events and executive networks have helped the world's leading companies understand the present and shape the future.

    Learn more about Membership

    • Who We Are
    • About Us
    • In the News
    • Press Releases
    • Our History
    • Support Our Work
    • Locations
    • Contact Us
    • Our Community
    • Our Leadership
    • Our Experts
    • Trustees
    • Voting Members
    • Careers
    • This Week @ TCB
Check if You're a Member
Create Account
Forgot Your Password?

Members of The Conference Board get exclusive access to the full range of products and services that deliver Trusted Insights for What's Ahead ® including webcasts, publications, data and analysis, plus discounts to conferences and events.

Labor Markets Briefs

Timely insights from the Economy, Strategy & Finance Center

  • Email
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Copy Link

The “Donut Effect” is real

January 06, 2022

A new trend has emerged since the beginning of the pandemic: demand for goods and services has significantly shifted away from city centers and toward less dense surrounding areas, which has been termed the “donut effect.” This shift in demand has impacted jobs. Below we provide new evidence that shows that since the beginning of the pandemic, employment declined more in city centers, than in other areas. The larger employment drop in city centers was especially notable in food services and retail businesses, because of the large decline in spending in city centers by workers who commute to these areas.

Most of this shift, as well as the increase in remote work, is likely to last for many years. Due to the donut effect, businesses will continue to adjust their employment footprint across geographies. Businesses that are in the forefront of making this shift will have a first-mover advantage.

This shift away from city centers has been largely impacted by remote work. During the pandemic, a large share of office workers has worked primarily from home. Many of them will continue to work from home in the foreseeable future. The rise of remote work will significantly impact where people live and work. The initial impact is made up of two trends: First, Millions more people spend their days in their homes as opposed to in their office in a city center. Second, millions of households may be moving further away from city centers where office employment is concentrated.

Measuring the Donut Effect

 

The main challenge of measuring the “donut effect” in employment is that the concept of the “city center” is not well defined and is not measured in official statistics. A useful indicator that an area is a city center is a high employment-to-population ratio. Using county level employment and population data, we find that in some metro areas there are single counties that have a much higher employment-to-population ratios, and significantly overlap with what would be considered the city center. In the analysis below, we focus on city center counties in five cities (New York, San Francisco, Washington DC, Atlanta, and Boston) and compare them to other counties in their respective metro areas, which we refer to as periphery counties. In other large metro areas, there were no individual counties that could be accurately used as proxies for city centers.

Less than 15 percent of US workers are employed in these metro areas, so it is not certain that the trends presented below accurately reflect other metro areas. But we do believe that the trends in other large metro areas, that experienced a large shift to remote work, are similar.

We utilized Bureau of Labor Statistics quarterly data on county-level employment to compute employment growth from Q4 of 2019 to Q2 of 2021, the latest available quarter.

The Donut Effect in Employment

 

Between 2019 Q4 and 2021 Q2, employment in these five city centers fell by an average of 10.6 percent. However, employment fell by much less in the surrounding counties, at an average of 5.9 percent. The largest difference was in New York City, where employment fell by 16.3 percent in New York County, which is Manhattan, but only 7.2 percent in the surrounding area (the rest of the New York–Newark–Jersey City metropolitan statistical area). Not all the change between city center and periphery counties is just due to decisions made by employers and workers. Part of it may be due to local governments decisions regarding pandemic related restrictions.

Chart 1 - Employment fell more in city center counties

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and calculations by The Conference Board

Averaging across these five cities, chart 2 shows that the divergence in employment growth between city centers and other areas is a new trend that did not occur before the pandemic. If anything, employment in city centers grew faster in the years prior to the pandemic.

Chart 2 – The employment recovery in city centers was much weaker

The gap in employment change between city center counties and other counties, has been more notable for low-wage, in-person service jobs (Chart 3). Many of these jobs, like Food Services and Drinking Places, Retail, and Fitness and Recreational Sports Centers are types of jobs that have been affected by the reduction in the number of daily commuters to city centers. Some of these jobs may have shifted to the counties where workers live.

Chart 3 - The industry mix of the city center employment drop was driven by the large decline in spending in city centers by workers who commute to these areas 

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and calculations by The Conference Board

 

Online job ads also show the “Donut Effect

 

Help Wanted OnLine data also suggest reduced hiring within city centers as well. Using principal cities of metro areas as a proxy for city centers, Chart 4 shows the percentage change in the number of online job ads between February 2020 to November 2021 for five geographic groups in the United States: (1) principal cities in the largest 25 metro areas (e.g. New York City, Miami, Denver), (2) the principal cities in the next 75 largest metro areas, ranked 26-100 (e.g. Nashville, Milwaukee, Greenville, South Carolina), (3) the largest 25 metro areas excluding their principal cities (e.g. New York-Newark-Jersey City, excluding New York), (4) the next 75 largest metro areas excluding their principal cities, and (5) the rest of the country, which consists of smaller metro areas and non-metro area communities.

Principal cities experienced a much smaller increase in the number of online job ads during the pandemic, especially within large metro areas. Outside of principal cities, the number of online job ads rapidly increased. The weakness of principal cities was especially visible in food services occupations.

Chart 4 – The number of online job ads increased more outside of principal cities

Typically, changes in inter-regional in demand for goods and services and employment are very gradual. However, the evidence presented above suggests that the donut effect is leading to a relatively sharp shift from city centers to other areas.

The “Donut Effect” Moving Forward:

 

  1. When the pandemic gradually dies down, some workers are likely to return to the office, but the overall number of daily commuters is likely to be much smaller than in the pre-pandemic period due to the adoption of hybrid work models. These models may also lead to large variation in office attendance across the week, with Fridays and Mondays having less attendance than average.
  2. Households will continue to migrate to areas further away from city centers as they become more certain about the permanency of remote work options.
  3. The “donut effect” is likely to be more significant in regions where the prevalence of remote work is higher, such as the West Coast and the Northeast.
  4. To the extent our results could be generalized beyond the five metro areas used here, the large gap in economic growth between city centers and other areas will require an adjustment to the geographical footprint of many companies’ workforces. Businesses in services such as food services and retail, will have to expand existing operation or open new ones outside of city centers and downsize or close some of their operations in city centers.
  5. All else equal, the geographical shift described here will make labor shortages more severe in periphery counties in large metro areas.
  6. Companies that adjust the geographical footprint of their work force before others will have a first-mover advantage, establishing brand recognition, customer loyalty, and early purchase of resources before other competitors enter the region.

Download Brief
Great News!

You already have an account with The Conference Board.

Please try to login in with your email or click here if you have forgotten your password.

  • Download
  • Download Brief

Authors

Gad Levanon, PhD

Gad Levanon, PhD

Former Vice President, Labor Markets

Read BioGad Levanon, PhD

Michael Papadopoulos

Michael Papadopoulos

Former Associate Economist

Read BioMichael Papadopoulos

More From This Series

Brief

May Brings Mixed Jobs Data

June 06, 2025

Brief

Jobs Report: April Showers, Tariff Storm Looms

May 02, 2025

Brief

March Payrolls: The Calm Before the Tariff Storm

April 04, 2025

Brief

February Jobs Report Hints at Growing Uncertainty

March 07, 2025

Brief

Stability Underneath January’s Noisy Jobs Report

February 07, 2025

Brief

Q4 ECI Wage Deceleration Slows

February 07, 2025

View Less View More

Conference Board Sample Web Chat
chatbot-Icon TCB Logo
chatbot-Icon
Navigating Washington - Sign up to receive the latest business insights related to executive orders, new laws, and changing regulations.
ABOUT US
  • Who We Are
  • Annual Report
  • Our History
  • Our Experts
  • Our Leadership
  • In the News
  • Press Releases
MEMBERSHIP
  • Become a Member
  • Sign In to myTCB®
  • Access Experts
  • Member-Only Events
  • Data & Benchmarking
  • Manage Account
EXPLORE
  • Centers
  • Councils
  • Latest Research
  • Events
  • Webcasts
  • Podcasts
  • This Week @ TCB
CONTACT US
  • Americas
    +1 212 759 0900
    customer.service@tcb.org
  • Europe/Africa/Middle East
    +32 2 675 5405
    brussels@tcb.org
  • Asia
    Hong Kong | +852 2804 1000
    Singapore | +65 8298 3403
    service.ap@tcb.org
CAREERS
  • See Open Positions
Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Event Code of Conduct | Trademarks
© 2025 The Conference Board Inc. All rights reserved. The Conference Board and torch logo are registered trademarks of The Conference Board.
The use of all The Conference Board data and materials is subject to the Terms of Use. Reprint requests are reviewed individually and may be subject to additional fees.The Conference Board reserves the right to deny any request.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Event Code of Conduct | Trademarks
© 2025 The Conference Board Inc. All rights reserved. The Conference Board and torch logo are registered trademarks of The Conference Board.
The use of all data from The Conference Board data and materials is subject to the Terms of Use. Reprint requests are reviewed individually and may be subject to additional fees.The Conference Board reserves the right to deny any request.

Thank you for signing up. You will now receive CEO Insights for What's Ahead every Wednesday morning. You can unsubscribe at any time or manage your preferences to receive more content from The Conference Board.

Announcing The Conference Board AI Virtual Conference Series

Explore the Impact of AI on Your Business

Members receive complimentary registration - Learn more >>