How Microsoft Avoided the Peter Principle with Nadella
Our Privacy Policy has been updated! The Conference Board uses cookies to improve our website, enhance your experience, and deliver relevant messages and offers about our products. Detailed information on the use of cookies on this site is provided in our cookie policy. For more information on how The Conference Board collects and uses personal data, please visit our privacy policy. By continuing to use this Site or by clicking "ACCEPT", you acknowledge our privacy policy and consent to the use of cookies. 
Our Privacy Policy has been updated! Detailed information on the use of cookies on this site is provided in our cookie policy and our privacy policy. 
TCB Tourch
Loading...
  •  
    • NORTH AMERICA
    • EUROPE
    • ASIA
  • 2

    Close
    • Insights
        • Insights
        • Explore by Center
          • Explore by Center
          • The CEO Center

          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

          • The Conference Board of Canada

        • Explore by Content Type
          • Explore by Content Type
          • Reports

          • Upcoming Webcasts

          • On Demand Webcasts

          • Podcasts

          • Charts & Infographics

          • Explore All Research

          • Economic Indicators

        • Trending Topics
          • Trending Topics
          • Artificial Intelligence (AI) Hub

          • Climate Hub

          • Navigating Washington Hub

          • Geopolitics Hub

          • US Economic Forecast

          • Explore All Trending Topics

    • Events
        • Events
        • Upcoming Events
          • Upcoming Events
          • Employee Well-Being 2026

          • Innovation Awards Dinner

          • 2027: A Year in Preview

          • 2027 Corporate Communications & Brand Summit

          • 27th Annual Employee Health Care Conference - New York

          • Explore All Upcoming Events

        • Member-Exclusive Programs
          • Member-Exclusive Programs
          • Center Briefings

          • Expert Briefings

          • Experts Live

          • Roundtables

          • Working Groups

          • View All Member-Exclusive Programs

        • Explore More
          • Explore More
          • View All Upcoming Events, Programs, and Webcasts

          • TCB Speaker Bureau

          • Sponsor a Program

    • Data
        • Data
        • All Data

        • Data Central

        • Consumer Confidence Index®

        • TCB Benchmarking

        • Recession & Growth Trackers

        • Global Economic Outlook

        • Leading Economic Indicators

        • Help Wanted OnLine

        • Labor Markets

        • Measure of CEO Confidence

        • Global Gray Swans Tool

        • CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

    • Centers
        • Centers
        • Our Centers
          • Our Centers
          • The CEO Center

          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

          • The Conference Board of Canada

    • Councils
        • Councils
        • Find a Council
          • Find a Council
          • Economy, Strategy & Finance

          • Governance & Sustainability

          • Human Capital

          • Marketing & Communications

          • Canada Councils

          • Explore All Councils

        • Council Membership
          • Council Membership
          • What is a Council?

          • Benefits of Council Membership

          • Apply to a Council

    • Membership
        • Membership
        • Types of Membership
          • Types of Membership
          • Membership at a Glance

          • Executive

          • C-Suite

          • Leadership Team

          • Council

          • Higher Education

          • Insights

        • Already a Member?
          • Already a Member?
          • Check if Your Organization is a Member

          • Sign In to myTCB®

          • Executive Communities

          • Member-Exclusive Programs

          • Refer a Leader - Earn a Reward

    • About Us
        • About Us
        • Who We Are
          • Who We Are
          • About Us

          • In the News

          • Press Releases

          • Our History

          • Support Our Work

          • Locations

          • The Conference Board of Canada

          • Contact Us

        • Our Community
          • Our Community
          • Our Leadership

          • Our Experts

          • TCB Speaker Bureau

          • Trustees

          • Voting Members

          • Global Counsellors

          • Careers

          • This Week @ TCB

          • Continuing Education Credits (CEUs)

    • Careers
    • This Week @ TCB
    • Sign In to myTCB®
      • NORTH AMERICA
      • EUROPE
      • ASIA
    • Insights
      • Insights
      • Explore by Center
        • Explore by Center
        • The CEO Center

        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

        • The Conference Board of Canada

      • Explore by Content Type
        • Explore by Content Type
        • Reports

        • Upcoming Webcasts

        • On Demand Webcasts

        • Podcasts

        • Charts & Infographics

        • Explore All Research

        • Economic Indicators

      • Trending Topics
        • Trending Topics
        • Artificial Intelligence (AI) Hub

        • Climate Hub

        • Navigating Washington Hub

        • Geopolitics Hub

        • US Economic Forecast

        • Explore All Trending Topics

    • Events
      • Events
      • Upcoming Events
        • Upcoming Events
        • Employee Well-Being 2026

        • Innovation Awards Dinner

        • 2027: A Year in Preview

        • 2027 Corporate Communications & Brand Summit

        • 27th Annual Employee Health Care Conference - New York

        • Explore All Upcoming Events

      • Member-Exclusive Programs
        • Member-Exclusive Programs
        • Center Briefings

        • Expert Briefings

        • Experts Live

        • Roundtables

        • Working Groups

        • View All Member-Exclusive Programs

      • Explore More
        • Explore More
        • View All Upcoming Events, Programs, and Webcasts

        • TCB Speaker Bureau

        • Sponsor a Program

    • Data
      • Data
      • All Data

      • Data Central

      • Consumer Confidence Index®

      • TCB Benchmarking

      • Recession & Growth Trackers

      • Global Economic Outlook

      • Leading Economic Indicators

      • Help Wanted OnLine

      • Labor Markets

      • Measure of CEO Confidence

      • Global Gray Swans Tool

      • CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

    • Centers
      • Centers
      • Our Centers
        • Our Centers
        • The CEO Center

        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

        • The Conference Board of Canada

    • Councils
      • Councils
      • Find a Council
        • Find a Council
        • Economy, Strategy & Finance

        • Governance & Sustainability

        • Human Capital

        • Marketing & Communications

        • Canada Councils

        • Explore All Councils

      • Council Membership
        • Council Membership
        • Benefits of Council Membership

        • Apply to a Council

        • Our Program Directors

        • Refer a Leader - Earn a Reward

    • Membership
      • Membership
      • Types of Membership
        • Types of Membership
        • Membership at a Glance

        • Executive

        • C-Suite

        • Leadership Team

        • Council

        • Higher Education

        • Insights

      • Already a Member?
        • Already a Member?
        • Check if Your Organization is a Member

        • Sign In to myTCB®

        • Executive Communities

        • Member-Exclusive Programs

        • Refer a Leader - Earn a Reward

    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Who We Are
        • Who We Are
        • About Us

        • In the News

        • Press Releases

        • This Week @ TCB

        • Our History

        • Support Our Work

        • Locations

        • The Conference Board of Canada

        • Contact Us

      • Our Community
        • Our Community
        • Our Leadership

        • Our Experts

        • TCB Speaker Bureau

        • Trustees

        • Voting Members

        • Global Counsellors

        • Careers

        • This Week @ TCB

        • Continuing Education Credits (CEUs)

    • Careers
    • Sign In to myTCB®
    • Download TCB Insights App
  • Insights
    Insights

    Our research and analysis have helped the world's leading companies navigate challenges and seize opportunities for over 100 years.

    • Explore by Center
    • The CEO Center
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    • The Conference Board of Canada
    • Explore by Content Type
    • Reports
    • Upcoming Webcasts
    • On Demand Webcasts
    • Podcasts
    • Charts & Infographics
    • Economic Indicators
    • Trending Topics
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI) Hub
    • Climate Hub
    • Navigating Washington Hub
    • Geopolitics Hub
    • US Economic Forecast
    • Explore All Trending Topics
  • Events
    Events

    Our in-person and virtual events offer unmatched opportunities for professional development, featuring top experts and practitioners.

    • Upcoming Events
    • Employee Well-Being 2026

      December 07 - 09, 2026

      Innovation Awards Dinner

      January 19 - 20, 2027

      2027: A Year in Preview

      January 20, 2027

      2027 Corporate Communications & Brand Summit

      March 02 - 03, 2027

      27th Annual Employee Health Care Conference - New York

      March 22 - 24, 2027

    • Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Center Briefings
    • Expert Briefings
    • Experts Live
    • Roundtables
    • Working Groups
    • View All Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Explore More
    • View All Upcoming Events, Programs, and Webcasts
    • TCB Speaker Bureau
    • Sponsor a Program
    • Explore by Type
    • Events
    • Webcasts
    • Podcasts
    • Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Center Briefings
    • Expert Briefings
    • Experts Live
    • Roundtables
    • Working Groups
    • View All Member-Exclusive Programs
  • Data
    Corporate Disclosure Data

    TCB Benchmarking

    Real-time data visualizations to benchmark your governance, compensation, environmental, human capital management (HCM) and social practices against US public companies.

    Economic Data

    All Data

    Data Central

    One-stop portal for the entire suite of indicators

    Consumer Confidence Index®

    Labor Markets

    Measure of CEO Confidence

    Global Gray Swans Tool

    Prepare for high-impact events

     

    Recession & Growth Trackers

    Current & future state of 16 economies

    Global Economic Outlook

    Growth outlooks for 77 economies

    Leading Economic Indicators

    State of the business cycle for 12 global economies across Asia and Europe

    Help Wanted OnLine

    Status of the US job market

    Other Featured Data

    CMO+CCO Meter Dashboard

  • Centers
    Centers

    Centers offer access to world-class experts, research, events, and senior executive communities.

    Our Centers
    • The CEO Center
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    • The Conference Board of Canada
  • Councils
    Councils

    Councils are invitation-only, peer-led communities of senior executives that come together to exchange knowledge, accelerate career development, and advance their function.

    Find a Council
    • Economy, Strategy & Finance
    • Governance & Sustainability
    • Human Capital
    • Marketing & Communications
    • Canada Councils
    • Explore All Councils
    Council Membership
    • Benefits of Council Membership
    • Apply to a Council
    • Our Program Directors
    • Refer a Leader - Earn a Reward
  • Membership
    Membership

    Membership in The Conference Board arms top executives and their teams with an arsenal of knowledge, networks, and expertise that's unmatched in scope and depth.

    • Types of Membership
    • Membership at a Glance
    • Executive
    • C-Suite
    • Leadership Team
    • Council
    • Higher Education
    • Insights
    • Already a Member?
    • Check if Your Organization is a Member
    • Sign in to myTCB®
    • Executive Communities
    • Member-Exclusive Programs
    • Refer a Leader - Earn a Reward
  • About Us
    About Us

    The Conference Board is the global, nonprofit think tank and business membership organization that delivers Trusted Insights for What's Ahead®. For over 100 years, our cutting-edge research, data, events and executive networks have helped the world's leading companies understand the present and shape the future.

    • Who We Are
    • About Us
    • In the News
    • Press Releases
    • Our History
    • Support Our Work
    • Locations
    • The Conference Board of Canada
    • Contact Us
    • Our Community
    • Our Leadership
    • Our Experts
    • TCB Speaker Bureau
    • Trustees
    • Voting Members
    • Careers
    • This Week @ TCB
    • Continuing Education Credits (CEUs)
Check if You're a Member
Create Account
Forgot Your Password?

Members of The Conference Board get exclusive access to the full range of products and services that deliver Trusted Insights for What's Ahead ® including webcasts, publications, data and analysis, plus discounts to conferences and events.

Human Capital Briefs

How Microsoft Avoided the Peter Principle with Nadella

28 March 2014 / Brief

Download Brief
  • Email
  • Linkedin
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Copy Link

In one of the most widely scrutinized CEO successions ever, Microsoft directors selected insider Satya Nadella to run the company, only their third CEO pick in the firm’s nearly 40-year history.  His challenges will be enormous. For starters, he will be running a $75 billion+ enterprise with some 100,000 employees, an army of software engineers and many moving parts. For finishers, he will have to change its treads—redirect its strategy—while barreling down a highway with no map for what lies ahead.

Microsoft’s board had considered a revolving roster of candidates over the past several months, from Nokia’s former CEO Stephen Elop (now back at Microsoft) to Ford’s CEO Alan Mulally. In betting on 22-year Microsoft veteran Nadella, the board has wagered the house: Right pick, Microsoft stays competitive with the likes of Apple, Google, and Oracle; Wrong pick, Microsoft is stuck in 2nd gear, or worse.

The vital—though not-soon-to-be answered—question is whether Mr. Nadella brings the right leadership talents not only to run the show but also to grow the enterprise at the center of one of most turbulent and competitive frays on earth.  And that question is likely to be answered in the affirmative if the directors have managed to avoid the Peter Principle.

Those who have been around a bit will remember a book of that name by Laurence J. Peter.  He argued with plenty of supporting material that sometimes companies, having promoted executives to what they were really good at, elevate them one time too many. Great at mid-level, the managers were not game-ready for the next level.

Moreover, reaching the ultimate level of chief executive is not just another move up the corporate ladder. It is a “jump shift,” as Procter & Gamble chairman A.G. Lafley has described it. Prior jobs cannot totally prepare one for the elevated reality, especially when it now requires running the whole show. The stakes rise exponentially when the final level is the corner office because, unlike lesser destinations, the entire enterprise can be put at risk with the wrong choice.

Fortunately, history is not destiny, and that is no doubt why the Microsoft board, under the guidance of lead director John Thompson, devoted so many months to vetting their twenty-some finalists. And what was critical here, in our view, or at any major enterprise for that matter, is for the directors to take the time to watch the candidates in action and to drill down with bottoms up data. An apples-to-apples comparison of the finalists can be vital as well.

Consider the CEO succession process at pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline beginning in 2004 when chief executive Jean-Pierre Garnier said he would be exiting in three years. That gave the directors plenty of time, and with that luxury, they methodically narrowed the field to three strong successors, all on the inside. During the final year, they added three paths to gather a last round of data:

1) The CEO and directors assigned a year-long CEO-level project to each of the three finalists. The projects all touched on areas of great strategic concern to the company, and the directors required each of the candidates to report their appraisals and plans to the board.

2) The CEO and directors conducted a “450-degree” assessment of each of the candidates, an expansion of the traditional “360” to include an extra “90” degrees:  They asked fourteen executives who had worked with all three finalists to privately compare their strengths for the top job at hand.

3) They arranged for a one-on-one lunch or dinner for each of the three candidates with each of the company’s sixteen directors.

No one piece of evidence yielded a killer conclusion, but the three sources taken together led to the appointment of dark-horse candidate Andrew Witty as the next CEO.  Even the sitting CEO who knew the three finalists as well as anybody was surprised.

By way of underscoring the power of the bottom-up appraisal, America’s special forces have utilized a similar method in selecting those who will join the nation’s most elite missions. Gathering appraisals from other special-forces personnel on the final candidates—from fellow service members who have seen the finalists on the ground or even in combat—has proven a telling source.

Or consider managed-health care provider Humana’s decision in 2013 to recruit an outsider as its next chief executive. William J. McDonald, who chaired the board’s committee that led the succession process, explained why it had gone to the outside. “I think one of the biggest mistakes boards make is to assess people only in the context of their current jobs.” Becoming a CEO is a far more expansive and demanding job, and he and his fellow directors worried whether the inside talent was then ready for the catapult upward.  “People can change dramatically when they get the brass ring,” he warned.

Most CEO candidates for large companies—like Satya Nadella at Microsoft—emerge from within, and that by definition can give the board the time it needs to vet the candidates in these several ways. But even if insiders are not yet ready, Humana’s McDonald explained that succession is all about “lead time, lead time, lead time.”

Plenty of time also gives the CEO and directors an opportunity to ensure that the eventual insider finalists are given a chance to master the additional skills required for moving up, for transcending any Peter Principle limitations.

Here learn-by-doing can be essential, especially in acquiring an experience-informed ability to work with the directors, investors, analysts, and reporters.  And that extends as well to rounding out the candidates’ personal familiarity with a firm’s far-flung geography and its many technical functions.  Mentoring by the CEO and lead director can be vital here, as can service on another board or two.  When George Buckley served as CEO for innovative manufacturer 3M, he actively encouraged rising stars at the company to serve on outside boards, join quarterly analyst calls, and work directly with the media.

Finally, we appreciate from the experience of many firms that CEO succession should focus on candidates who are top-ranked not only for past performance but also for future challenges. Making that “strategic fit” was surely a factor in Microsoft’s selection of Mr. Nadella, who evidently brings a special appreciation for cloud computing and mobile devices, a new world that the next CEO has to face even if his predecessors had belatedly done so.

Microsoft investors, customers, and employees are all hoping that John Thompson and his board got it right, and that they have managed to avoid Peter’s pitfall to select the leadership that Microsoft requires in the years ahead.

 

This blog first appeared on Harvard Business Review on 2/6/2014.

View our complete listing of Strategic HR and Leadership Development blogs.

Great News!

You already have an account with The Conference Board.

Please try to login in with your email or click here if you have forgotten your password.

Create An Account



 

By Clicking 'Create Account', You Agree To Our Terms Of Use

Create Account
  • Download
  • Download Brief

Authors

Dennis Carey

Dennis Carey

Vice Chairman

Read BioDennis Carey

Michael Useem

Michael Useem

William and Jacalyn Egan Professor of Management

Read BioMichael Useem

More From This Series

Brief

Communication Is Key In Supporting Employee Well-Being

May 30, 2024

Brief

Three Ways Managers Can Calm Employees’ Fears About Returning To Work

May 17, 2021

Brief

Agile processes for stable teams

March 08, 2021

Brief

Survey: 35 Percent of US Companies Do Not Know When They’ll Reopen Workplace

October 19, 2020

Brief

Employee Readiness Reopening Survey: Only 28 Percent of Workers Expect Return to Workplace by End of 2020

October 19, 2020

Brief

Three Ways to Navigate Political Divides at Work

October 07, 2020

View Less View More

Conference Board Sample Web Chat
chatbot-Icon
TCB Logo
chatbot-Icon
C-Suite Insights - Sign up to receive weekly C-Suite Insights newsletters, updates, surveys, and other relevant email communications. Unsubscribe any time
WHO WE ARE
  • About Us
  • Our History
  • Our Experts
  • Our Leadership
  • In the News
  • Press Releases
  • Locations
EXPLORE
  • Membership
  • Centers
  • Councils
  • Reports
  • Events
 
  • Webcasts
  • Podcasts
  • Data
  • Ask TCB
  • This Week @ TCB
CONTACT US
  • North America
    +1 212 759 0900
    customer.service@tcb.org
  • EMEA
    +32 2 675 5405
    brussels@tcb.org
  • Asia
    Hong Kong | +852 2804 1000
    Singapore | +65 8298 3403
    service.ap@tcb.org
CAREERS
  • See Open Positions
Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Event Code of Conduct | Trademarks
© 2026 The Conference Board Inc. All rights reserved. The Conference Board and torch logo are registered trademarks of The Conference Board.
The use of all The Conference Board data and materials is subject to the Terms of Use. Reprint requests are reviewed individually and may be subject to additional fees.The Conference Board reserves the right to deny any request.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Event Code of Conduct | Trademarks
© 2026 The Conference Board Inc. All rights reserved. The Conference Board and torch logo are registered trademarks of The Conference Board.
The use of all data from The Conference Board data and materials is subject to the Terms of Use. Reprint requests are reviewed individually and may be subject to additional fees.The Conference Board reserves the right to deny any request.

Thank you for signing up. You will now receive CEO Insights for What's Ahead every Wednesday morning. You can unsubscribe at any time or manage your preferences to receive more content from The Conference Board.

Important: Your Membership subscription payment is past due. We have not yet received your Membership payment. Please click the button below to pay your invoice.

Pay Invoice

Announcing The Conference Board AI Virtual Conference Series

Explore the Impact of AI on Your Business

Members receive complimentary registration - Learn more >>